Food
Menu
Explore our mouthwatering food menu, showcasing a diverse selection of casual American cuisine. From classic burgers and hearty sandwiches to savory comfort dishes, including our renowned John Cross Whitefish Fry, our menu caters to every craving.
Apps
Nachos
Vegetarian Friendly
Corn tortilla chips baked with beer cheese, black beans, and cheddar. Topped with napa slaw, tomato, jalapeno and chile lime crema.
$14.99
Add Grilled Chicken $4.99
Add Avocado $1.99
Maple Crack Dip
Favorite
Made in house with roasted chicken, Frank’s RedHot, local maple syrup, green onions, cream cheese and baked with bleu cheese. Served with tortilla chips
$14.49
Hand Battered Cheese Curds
Vegetarian Friendly
White cheddar, beer battered and deep fried. Topped with ranch, buffalo sauce and green onion.
$13.49
Onion Rings
Vegetarian Friendly
Beer battered and deep fried. Served with pesto ranch.
$9.99
Beer Cheese Dip
Vegetarian Friendly
House-made with Bell’s Two Hearted and served with warm house fried potato chips.
$9.49
Pub Pretzel
Favorite
Vegetarian Friendly
Bavarian pretzels buttered, salted, and baked, served with our house made beer cheese
$13.99
From Holland with Love
Crispy Brussels sprouts, balsamic glaze, parmesan, toasted almonds and bacon.
$12.99
Chicken Wings
8 jumbo wings, deep fried and tossed in your choice of buffalo, Asian sticky, or house BBQ sauce.
$15.99
Peel N‘ Eat Shrimp
Favorite
Boiled and bagged. Choose from Old Bay seasoning or garlic butter.
One Dozen $16.99
Two Dozen $23.99
Soups & Salads
Turkey Cobb Salad
Plath’s smoked turkey and bacon, avocado, hard boiled egg, cucumber, tomato, white cheddar, croutons, and ranch.
Regular $17.49
Small $13.49
Add Grilled Chicken $4.99
Add Shrimp $7.99
Add Avocado $1.99
Pub Salad
Vegetarian Friendly
Greens, tomato, almonds, Parmesan, fried sprouts, cucumber, croutons and balsamic vinaigrette.
Regular $14.99
Small $10.99
Add Grilled Chicken $4.99
Add Shrimp $7.99
Add Avocado $1.99
LSP Salad
Vegetarian Friendly
Greens, cucumber, tomato, onion, croutons, and choice of dressing
$7.99
Add Grilled Chicken $4.99
Add Shrimp $7.99
Add Avocado $1.99
Cream of Tomato
Vegetarian Friendly
Cup $3.99
Bowl $5.99
Drunken Clam Chowder
House-made with Short’s Locals Light.
Cup $5.49
Bowl $7.49
Handhelds
All sandwiches are served with house fried potato chips.
Upgrade to waffle fries or onion rings for $3.49
Gluten free bun $3.49
Whitefish Sandwich
Favorite
Beer battered John Cross Whitefish, mustard slaw, tomato, on a toasted kaiser bun.
$14.99
The Brick Layer
Ham, salami, pepperoni, Italian sausage, onion, provolone, baked on a garlic butter hoagie bun.
Half $13.99
Whole $17.99
The Italian Stallion
Salami, ham, pepperoni, Italian dressing, Swiss cheese, giardiniera, lettuce, and tomato on a hoagie bun.
Half $13.99
Whole $16.99
Cali Club Wrap
Plath’s smoked turkey and bacon, avocado, lettuce, tomato and pesto ranch in a tomato tortilla.
$14.49
Chicken Sandwich
Pickle-brined chicken breast, hand floured and fried. Mixed lettuce, pickles, bacon, Swiss cheese and honey dijon mustard, on a toasted kaiser bun.
$15.99
Club
Three slices malted wheat bread stacked high with Plath’s smoked ham, turkey and bacon; American cheese, Swiss cheese, iceberg lettuce, tomato and Duke’s mayo.
$15.99
Reuben
Favorite
House smoked and pulled corned beef, Swiss cheese, sauerkraut and thousand island dressing on grilled rye bread.
$15.49
PJ’s Grilled Cheese
Vegetarian Friendly
Malted wheat bread, grilled with garlic butter, American, Swiss and Cheddar cheese. Served with house-made cream of tomato soup.
$12.99
French Dip
Favorite
Grilled ribeye steak and melted provolone cheese on a toasted bun served with au jus.
Half $16.99
Whole $21.99
Pub Burgers
Lake Street Pub’s famous, custom blend smash burgers. 2oz patties seasoned, smashed and grilled. Served on a toasted Kaiser bun with house fried potato chips.
Upgrade to waffle fries or onion rings for 3.49
Additional patties 2.49 ea. Gluten free bun 3.49
LSP Burger
Favorite
2 smash patties loaded with American cheese.
$10.99
Deluxe Add $0.49
Olive Burger
Favorite
4 smash patties topped with cheese, Duke’s mayo and lots of sliced green olives.
$15.49
Old Faithful
4 smash patties loaded with American cheese topped with fresh lettuce, tomato, onion and dill pickle.
$15.49
Mushroom & Swiss
4 smash patties topped with grilled mushrooms and loaded with Swiss cheese.
$15.49
PJ’s Grilled Cheese Burger
4 smash patties stuffed in our house grilled cheese.
$15.49
Cheddar Bacon
4 smash patties topped with cheddar cheese and Plath’s crispy bacon.
$16.49
Impossible TM Burger
Vegetarian Friendly
1/4 lb grilled plant patty topped with fresh lettuce, tomato, onion and pickle.
$15.99
Signature Plates
Peel n’ Eat Shrimp
Favorite
Boiled and bagged with Old Bay or garlic butter. Served with garlic butter mashed potatoes or waffle fries, broccoli, and a split-top grilled roll.
One Dozen $19.99
Two Dozen $26.99
Chicken Alfredo
Penne Pasta tossed with creamy alfredo sauce, grilled chicken breast and broccoli.
$18.99
Fire Braised Ribs
St. Louis cut pork ribs, fire braised and smothered in your choice of house specialty Asian sticky sauce, or house BBQ. Served with garlic butter mashed potatoes or waffle fries and broccoli.
$24.99
Bier Mac n’ Cheese
Penne pasta tossed with Bell’s Two Hearted ale cheese sauce, Plath’s bacon and potato chip crumble.
$16.49
Add Grilled Chicken $4.99
Add Shrimp $7.99
Whitefish Fry
House signature beer batter dunked and deep fried. Served with waffle fries and napa slaw.
2 pieces $20.99
Additional Pieces $4.99
Broiled Whitefish
Seasoned and served with broccoli and choice of garlic butter mashed potatoes or waffle fries.
$20.99
Sides
Waffle Fries
Vegetarian Friendly
Broccoli & Beer Cheese
Vegetarian Friendly
Mustard Slaw
Vegetarian Friendly
House Fried Potato Chips
Vegetarian Friendly
Beer Battered Onion Rings
Vegetarian Friendly
Kids
Chicken Strips
Served with waffle fries or fruit cup
$10.99
Cheeseburger
Served with waffle fries or fruit cup
$10.50
Buttered Noodles
Vegetarian Friendly
Penne pasta & butter. Served with a fruit cup.
$7.99
Mac n’ Cheese
Vegetarian Friendly
The classic, cheese sauce and noodles. Served with a fruit cup.
$8.99
Cheese Pizza
Vegetarian Friendly
$12.99
Add Pepperoni $2
Favorite
Vegetarian Friendly
Ask your server about menu items that are cooked to order or served raw.
Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness.